Frustration and fury at a former Minister’s trial in Egypt

Crowds of people struggled to enter the court to share their anger over relatives killed during protests © Demotix

By Amnesty International’s team in Cairo

“Why should he be tried for corruption only,” shouted the father of one of the victims, referring to the former Minister of Interior Habib Ibrahim El Adly. His voice was hoarse from shouting as he waited all morning under the hot sun with a large poster of his son, unable to get to the courtroom.
He was not alone in his suffering. Many relatives of those who died or were injured during the uprising shared in his struggle to get into the courtroom of Cairo Criminal Court, which is in New Cairo, in the desert east of the capital.
Since early morning, a heavy security presence surrounded the court. Only one access point was allowed. As only a few people were trickling in, the majority shouted their fury at police. They shouted at the army officers for making what should have been a normal entrance into the courtroom a painful experience filled with tears and helplessness. An army commander insisted that he would not let anybody pass until the some 100 people formed a single queue.
We explained to him that we represent Amnesty International and had come to observe the trial. We asked if he was barring the way on orders from the presiding judge. He appeared offended and responded that he does not receive orders from a judge but only from the military leadership. He sarcastically said we should go and observe trials at the International Court of Justice. Eventually, he took our business cards and accreditation letters and came back saying we would be allowed in, only to disappear afterwards.
Lawyers, too, were blocked on the pretext that people were unable to enter the court in an orderly fashion. After pushing and shoving, the lawyers, the relatives and the media were able to move beyond the first barrier, thinking they would finally reach the court room and see the former Minister of Interior and other senior security officers in the defendants’ cage, standing trial on charges of killing unarmed protesters.
But this initial sense of success was short-lived. More than 100 metres from the courtroom, another line of iron bars and a chain of Central Security officers blocked their way. As army officers asked people to calm down and listen, one young man said “we have been listening for the last 30 years. You need to listen to us now”. “The police and the army are one hand”, sniped a lawyer, mocking a popular slogan during the “25 January Revolution” – “the people and the army are one hand”.
Pleading and arguments got the crowd nowhere, with many still barred from accessing the court. Only after long negotiations and showing the army officers their identification were a few lawyers allowed to enter. We spoke to BBC Arabic reporters about our plans to observe the trial. After we again told the police officer that we were from a human rights organization, he allowed us and some lawyers to pass.

Security forces installed a series of barriers to limit access to the courtroom where El Adly's trial took place © Demotix

We passed two barriers where we had our bags searched. We thought we would finally be able to enter the courtroom and get on with observing the trial. But, with only a few meters to go until the main courtroom door, we could not advance anymore. Another metal barrier and a line of security officials stood between us and the courtroom. We were told the courtroom was too packed to allow any more people in. At the door, the brother of one of the victims pleaded with the soldiers to let him enter: “They have killed my brother, I have the right to enter”, he shouted to no avail, clearly frustrated and furious that the security forces had denied him access to the trial.

After five minutes, the door opened and we thought that some more people were going to be allowed inside. However, people began streaming out, saying the session had ended.
Families who managed to enter the courtroom also shouted their fury and frustration that nobody was able to see the defendants in the cage as police agents blocked the view. The judge, seen by lawyers and families as taking side with the ousted Mubarak government, left the courtroom minutes after opening the session. He decided to postpone the trial for a month, delaying at the same time the justice craved by the victims and their families.
When we left the building, family members gathered to shout their criticism of Egypt’s Public Prosecutor and the government for ignoring their demands and failing to deliver justice.
Among them were three relatives of Cairo protesters killed in the “25 January Revolution” who were mentioned in Amnesty International’s report, Egypt Rises: Killings, detentions  and torture in the ’25 January Revolution’.
Mohamed El-Wakil (know as Abu Khaled, the father of Khaled, who was killed), from the working class neighbourhood of El Matareya, north of Cairo, had managed to enter the court, only to come out furious. He led the chants, holding a copy of Amnesty International’s report in his hand.
Camera crews filmed the families as they chanted against injustice. They loudly promised to take part in the new mass protests planned for Friday 27 May, dubbed “another Friday of anger” to demand a “clean up of the judiciary” and to reject any “deal” that would deny them justice and allow former President Hosni Mubarak to escape trial and go unpunished.
Posted in Censorship and Free Speech, Egypt, Middle East And North Africa | 3 Comments

  1. Ahmed Taher says:

    Protesting at the court vicinity is againest a fair trial regardless the claimed grave crimes done by the detained person.

  2. The old regimes will not give up easily. The people need to return to the streets again and again.

  3. Habib Ibrahim El Adly has been sentenced to 12 years for money laundering. Obviously he should have been tried for killing as well. As in the case of Al Capone, you take the justice you can get.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>