‘What does Europe want from us?’ – Migrants detained for months on end in Greece

Migrants are often held for months on end in Greek detention centres like this one in Tychero in the Evros region © Bradley Secker / Demotix

By Irem Arf Rayfield, Researcher on Refugee and Migrants’ Rights in Europe

Flying back from our research mission in Greece, I can’t shake off the image of exhaustion in the eyes of the newly arrived migrants on the island of Lesvos when describing their dangerous journey across the Aegean Sea.

The same fatigue was shared by Syrian women we met in Athens – forced to leave their loved ones behind when they fled to Greece – where they now live in fear of racist attacks and the perils for their children in a merciless urban setting.

And finally the suffering of migrants and refugees held for months in the detention centres and police stations in north-eastern Greece, where our mission came to an end.

Migrants and refugees fleeing conflict and destitution have been funnelled towards this area where the Evros River marks the Greece-Turkey border and Europe’s frontier.

The mass movement of people has been met with a massive security response. In August 2012, 1,800 police officers were deployed to the border to crack down on irregular migration under Operation Aspida (Shield) and a 10.5km fence north of the Evros River was erected later in the year.

“Almost no one can cross anymore,” the police in the region tell us proudly. “There has been only one drowning this year so far.” Operation Aspida might have contributed to the decrease in deaths to drowning and hypothermia, but another tragedy continues to take place on the fertile land west of the Evros.

The very few migrants who now manage to cross the border and those arrested during sweep operations in Greek cities are locked up for months in police stations and the detention centres you can find in almost every town here.

Our throats burn from the foul air in the damp and dark cells of police stations we visit. Although the police agree that these cells were designed to hold people overnight, migrants and refugees – mostly young men, but also some women and even unaccompanied children – often spend months within their walls.

I was forewarned about appalling conditions, but nothing could have prepared me for this. How can such places exist in this day and age, in Europe? Detention facilities surrounded by barbed wire; filthy, cold and damp cells where people spend months, going days on end without any exercise; toilets and showers where some detainees explain they have to hold their breaths not to faint due to the smell.
In Tychero, migrants and refugees talk to us through the small viewing window on the black steel door of their cell. When we tell them that we’re not allowed inside their cells, one says “I’ll tell you why they don’t let you in; no human being can stay here. A dog cannot live here. We eat, sit, sleep, shit here, and we look out of this window. They don’t want you to see how we live here.”

In Fylakio, they complain that their blankets haven’t been washed or changed since they arrived; some say they have been sleeping on the same mattress without a sheet for over six months.

Hygiene and health risks are a major problem. Just three months ago, we are told, a scabies outbreak affected almost all detention centres and police stations in the region. “I came here healthy, now I am sick,” says a young man who cannot stop scratching his arms, legs and head.

All complain that they are unable to sleep and that suicide attempts are not uncommon. “This place makes us crazy, no one can remain sane here,” say a group of Bangladeshi migrants in Fylakio.

Mobile phones are banned at almost all facilities. Public phones can be used with phone cards; each costing €4. People tell us that they don’t last long; one minute for a call to Somalia, possibly two minutes to Afghanistan. They are unable to receive calls from outside. A Somali man explains that he has not been able to talk to his children in Somalia for nine months because he has no money to buy a phone card.

However, migrants are more concerned about the length of their detention. Anyone can be held up to 18 months now – irregular migrants and asylum seekers alike. In another facility, a young Eritrean man interrupts his friend who was informing us about the poor conditions: “Clean rooms, clean beds, warm shower – none of that will change anything. Don’t help us if that’s all you’re going to ask for. What we need is freedom.”

“What does Europe want from us?” asks a Guinean man in one of the large detention centres we visit. “I have been here for nine months, they say they can keep me another nine. Then they will give me a paper to leave Greece in seven days. How can I arrange to leave Greece in seven days? I cannot even make a phone call here. They will just arrest me again.”

In big detention facilities like Fylakio and Komotini, the tension is palpable. The suffering and frustration of men and women stripped off their freedom in the many holding places in the Evros region. They cry that they are not criminals. An Afghan man asks me: “We haven’t killed anyone, we didn’t rob any place; so why are we being punished like this? For just lacking a piece of paper?”

Our last visit takes us to the police station in Iasmos, which is holding two unaccompanied children waiting indefinitely until space opens up in a children’s shelter. After months in Komotini, they were transferred to Iasmos to be separated from adult detainees, when they were eventually documented as children.

It is difficult to imagine how anyone could spend even a day in these cold bare cells, sleeping on mattresses thrown on the raw cement floor, and even more difficult to comprehend how children could be confined here. One boy has already been here for about a month; the other a few weeks without exercise or fresh air. Both are distressed and unable to grasp why they are being held here.

Throughout our conversation one is teary-eyed while the other looks down at the floor and constantly repeats, “I am tired, I am tired.”

Read more:

Greece: Despair pervades camps after 33 migrant workers shot in Manolada (Feature, 22 April 2013)
‘The world needs to know what’s happening here’ – Migrants living on the margins in Athens (Blog, 16 April 2013)
‘Why don’t they just send me back to die?’ – Migrants despair on Europe’s borders (Blog, 12 April 2013)

Posted in Asylum, Greece, Migrants, Refugees | Tagged , , | 4 Comments

  1. Stella says:

    It is appalling that my country is treating these immigrants so badly when their only crime is to flee their own countries due to fear of wars, crime, poverty etc. One of the biggest problems we are facing here is the lack of resources in order to help so many thousands of immigrants who are entering the borders daily when we cannot even take care of our own citizens. The larger and wealthier nations of the EU refuse to help in any way (contrary to immigration laws of the EU) to allow any of the immigrants we are hosting into their own borders to alleviate these problems of the smallest and poorest nation of the EU. There is severe racial tension here from all sides which is very convenient for the politicians of each county who profit from these tensions in order to take whatever wealth our country can provide i.e. oil, gold etc. The EU and our forced induction into the Euro monetary unit (elections were not held for the public to decide if we want to enter the Euro) has done major disservice to our country with no hopes of things getting better here any time soon. The public is extremely fed up with the extreme corruption here and are trying to fight back, unfortunately far too often the frustrations we endure are taken out on the innocent who are only trying to survive themselves. We all need to band together (natives and immigrants) to rise up in revolution in order to overthrow the corrupt government we have and fight against the foreign powers that are dictating (as in dictatorship) our fates here i.e Germany, Troika, IMF etc.

    • Spyro says:

      This is so demoralizing to me as a Greek immigrant, whos family came to America, did ok, and then sent money back to our relatives in Greece. I see immigrant Greeks on various social networks around the world who support the fascist tactics going on back home and itsickens me. They should be ashamed.

  2. Liposom Diet says:

    You actually make it seem so easy together with your presentation but I in finding
    this topic to be actually something which I think I’d by no means understand.
    It kind of feels too complex and very extensive for me.
    I’m taking a look forward in your subsequent put up, I’ll attempt
    to get the cling of it!

  3. chris says:

    I care formost for the security of my family walking after 7 o’clock in the afternoon out on the streets of athens than I do about any illegal immigrant.
    Plenty of Athens neighborhoods are under foreign occupation. The fear on the eyes of the greek people is heartbreaking.
    I do consider the political elite as morally responsible for that, the illegal immigrant who tries to cross the border should be expecting all sorts of difficulties.
    Botom line, illegal immigrants made our lives living hell and the only sympathy they get is out of fear. Nothing else.

    I’m not counting on those, all those hard working, decent immigrants. But it IS illegal immigration that has destroyed and bruised the athenian population.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>